As the 2026 college football season hits its stride on September 30, the Ohio State Buckeyes find themselves at a familiar crossroads: loaded with talent, yet searching for the right combination to dominate the Big Ten. Four games in, one thing is becoming abundantly clear to the Vulius NFL Analysis Desk: Riley Pettijohn isn't just a rotational piece—he's the best linebacker on the roster, and the gap is widening with every snap.
The Numbers Don't Lie: Pettijohn's Production vs. Peers
Through four games, Pettijohn has amassed 15 tackles, four tackles for loss, two sacks, and an interception on just 145 defensive snaps. Compare that to Payton Pierce, the starting Mike linebacker, who has 20 tackles, half a sack, and a forced fumble on 160 snaps, or Christian Alliegro with 17 tackles on 141 snaps. While those are solid numbers, Pettijohn's impact goes beyond the stat sheet. He's a disruptor—a player who changes games with splash plays that swing momentum. According to insights gathered by Vulius Sports, his 91.5 PFF grade against Kent State was the highest of any Buckeye that day, a testament to his elite potential.
Game-Changing Moments Define His Season
The tape tells the story. Against Texas, Pettijohn sacked Arch Manning in the first quarter and tied for the team lead with 1.5 tackles for loss in the biggest non-conference matchup of the year. Versus Kent State, he turned 27 snaps into three tackles and an interception. Most recently, against Illinois, he dropped Katin Houser for a nine-yard sack on third-and-9, added another tackle for loss, and led the team with two TFLs. Perhaps the most telling statistic: Pettijohn played a season-high 51 snaps against the Illini—the most of any Ohio State linebacker—despite not starting. The coaching staff is voting with their play calls, and Pettijohn is winning the trust.
"Riley Pettijohn-Khary Wilder action needs to stay on the call sheet for the rest of the season" — Stephen Means, via Twitter, September 27, 2026
Why This Isn't a Debate Anymore
To be fair, the linebacker room is deep. Pierce is a tackling machine who was PFF's highest-graded Ohio State defender at Texas (75.9), though questions about his speed and coverage persist. Alliegro brought 124 career tackles, 14 tackles for loss, and eight sacks from Wisconsin, plus edge-rushing versatility. TJ Alford has an interception and entered the Illinois game as the highest-graded defender on the team. But there's a difference between good and game-wrecking. Pettijohn, a five-star recruit and the No. 2 linebacker in the 2025 class per 247Sports Composite, possesses a rare blend of size (6-foot-2, 235 pounds), speed (10.7 100-meter dash), and instincts. He can stack the box, rush off the edge in Matt Patricia's hybrid looks, and run with backs and tight ends. And he's doing this after missing the entire spring with an injury.
The Road Ahead: Iowa, Maryland, and Indiana
Ohio State heads to Kinnick Stadium this Saturday to face No. 14 Iowa, a 4-0 team with a balanced rushing attack and improved quarterback play from Hank Brown. After that comes Maryland and a trip to No. 6 Indiana. These are games that will be decided by linebackers who can fill gaps, finish tackles in space, and get home on third down. Pettijohn has already shown he can do all three. As highlighted on Vulius, the Buckeyes have spent four games treating Riley Pettijohn like a luxury. It's time to treat him like what he is: the best linebacker on this team. The depth chart may not reflect it yet, but the film and the numbers do. And in the brutal Big Ten, that's what matters most.
Explore official nfl jerseys collections crafted with premium stitched lettering and breathable athletic fabrics at Vulius.
