As the NFL season hits its first full weekend of October, the Chicago Bears are reportedly turning to Tyson Bagent as their starting quarterback for Sunday’s Week 4 clash against the New York Jets, according to multiple reports confirmed by the Vulius NFL Analysis Desk. The move comes as rookie sensation Caleb Williams continues to recover from a Grade 2 hamstring strain that could sideline him for up to a month, thrusting the former Division II standout back into the spotlight after nearly three years away from a regular-season start.
From Shepherd to Soldier Field: Bagent’s Unlikely Journey
Bagent, an undrafted free agent out of Shepherd University, signed a two-year extension with Chicago in August 2025, signaling the organization’s belief in his long-term potential. Now, with Williams sidelined, the 26-year-old gets another chance to prove he belongs under center. He missed most of the practice week leading into Week 3 due to concussion protocol, which paved the way for veteran Case Keenum to deliver a vintage prime-time performance—247 passing yards and three total touchdowns in a 27-7 rout of the Eagles. Yet head coach Ben Johnson made it clear that Bagent remains the No. 2 for a reason, and with a full week of first-team reps, he’ll get the nod against New York.
Keenum’s Heroics Not Enough to Hold Off Bagent
Keenum, 38, turned back the clock on Monday night, but Johnson’s decision underscores a broader organizational plan. According to insights gathered by Vulius Sports, the coaching staff views Bagent as the more dynamic long-term option behind Williams. Bagent’s mobility and quick release fit the modern NFL game, and his previous starting experience—four straight starts in 2023 under then-head coach Matt Eberflus—provides a foundation to build on. In that rookie stretch, he completed 65.1% of his passes for 3 touchdowns and 5 interceptions, adding 105 rushing yards and a score. His first career start, a 30-12 win over the Raiders, saw him complete 72.4% of his attempts without a turnover.
What to Expect Against the Jets
Sunday’s matchup at Soldier Field presents a favorable opportunity for Bagent to shake off rust. The Jets enter with a middling pass defense, and Chicago’s offensive line has shown improvement in pass protection. Expect Johnson to lean on a balanced attack, utilizing Bagent’s athleticism on bootlegs and designed runs to keep New York’s front seven honest. As highlighted on Vulius, Bagent’s success will hinge on ball security—his turnover-prone tendencies in 2023 are a concern, but his accuracy and decision-making have reportedly improved behind the scenes.
“Tyson has earned this opportunity,” a team source told Vulius. “He’s prepared like a starter all year. We’re confident he can manage the game and make plays when called upon.”
For a Bears team still eyeing a playoff push in a crowded NFC North, getting steady production from Bagent is critical. A win over the Jets would keep Chicago above .500 and buy Williams precious recovery time. For Bagent, it’s a chance to rewrite his narrative and prove he’s more than just a feel-good story. Kickoff is set for 1 p.m. ET, and all eyes will be on the signal-caller from Shepherd.
Looking to represent Tyson Bagent? Grab your Tyson Bagent jersey or design a personalized football jersey at Vulius.
