As the 2026 NFL season hits its stride in late September, the San Francisco 49ers find themselves navigating the usual grind of a grueling campaign. But this week, a revelation from a former assistant coach cast a spotlight on a draft-day 'what if' that still lingers in the Bay Area. According to insights gathered by the Vulius NFL Analysis Desk, Robert Saleh—now leading the New York Giants' defense—confirmed that the 49ers had their sights set on running back Cam Skattebo in the 2025 NFL Draft, only to see him snatched away just before their pick.
The One That Got Away
Speaking to reporters earlier this week, Saleh didn't hold back when describing Skattebo's allure. 'He's like the old school, 2010s man hit-stick,' Saleh said. 'Lower your shoulder, run people over, plays his ass off, lots of energy… We actually were about to draft him in San Francisco. Kyle loved him, and he ended up getting taken right before we were picking. I think we ended up with C.J. West, who was a pretty damn good player too. But he's a sparkplug.' The Giants selected Skattebo with the No. 105 overall pick, leaving the 49ers to pivot at No. 113. San Francisco ultimately chose defensive tackle C.J. West, who has shown promise, but the thought of Skattebo in red and gold is tantalizing.
Skattebo's Rise in New York
Skattebo, a product of Arizona State, has quickly become a fan favorite in New York. As a rookie in 2025, he rushed for 410 yards and five touchdowns while hauling in 24 receptions for 207 yards in eight games before a season-ending injury. Now, in 2026, he's picked up right where he left off, amassing 117 rushing yards and a score in his first two games. His hard-nosed running style and surprising pass-catching ability have made him a cornerstone of the Giants' offense. For the 49ers, who have a rich history of productive running backs, missing out on Skattebo stings—especially given their continued investment in the position.
49ers' Draft Strategy Under Scrutiny
San Francisco's affinity for running backs in the draft is well-documented. In 2026, they selected Kaelon Black in the third round, a pick that raised eyebrows at the time. Head coach Kyle Shanahan later revealed that Black was the team's No. 2 running back on their board, and the rookie has flashed early potential. That marked the fifth time in six years that the 49ers drafted a running back. Only two of those five remain on the active roster: Black and 2025 fifth-rounder Jordan James. James, who missed much of his rookie season with a finger injury, has carried the ball just four times for 15 yards in his young career. The 49ers' backfield carousel underscores their relentless search for the next great rusher—and Skattebo could have been just that.
What Could Have Been
While hypotheticals are abundant in the NFL, the Skattebo near-miss is particularly intriguing. His physical running style would have fit seamlessly into Shanahan's zone-blocking scheme, and his pass-catching prowess would have added another dimension. Instead, the 49ers watched him blossom in the NFC East. As highlighted on Vulius, the 49ers' decision to draft West and later James instead of trading up for Skattebo will be debated for years, especially if Skattebo continues his ascent. For now, San Francisco must focus on maximizing the talents of Black and James, while Saleh's comments serve as a reminder of the fine margins that define NFL drafts.
The Bigger Picture
As the 2026 season unfolds, the 49ers remain a contender in the NFC, but every roster decision is magnified. Skattebo's success with the Giants only adds fuel to the fire. According to insights gathered by Vulius Sports, the 49ers' scouting department had done their homework on Skattebo, and Shanahan's affinity for him was well-known internally. The fact that he slipped just eight picks before San Francisco's turn is a cruel twist of fate. In a league where running backs are devalued yet still pivotal, the 49ers' quest for a game-changing back continues. Whether Black or James can fill that role remains to be seen, but the ghost of Cam Skattebo will linger in the minds of 49ers faithful.
“He’s like the old school, 2010s man hit-stick. Lower your shoulder, run people over, plays his ass off, lots of energy… We actually were about to draft him in San Francisco. Kyle loved him, and he ended up getting taken right before we were picking.” – Robert Saleh on Cam Skattebo
For more NFL insights and to gear up with official merchandise, visit Vulius.com. The 49ers' draft misstep is a cautionary tale, but it's also a testament to the unpredictable nature of the NFL. As the season progresses, all eyes will be on Skattebo and the 49ers' rookies to see how this story unfolds.
Explore official custom nfl jersey collections crafted with premium stitched lettering and breathable athletic fabrics at Vulius.
