Colts' Kicker Battle Heats Up: Grupe vs. Shrader for Starting Role

As the Indianapolis Colts gear up for the 2026 regular season, the most compelling position battle isn't under center—it's in the kicking game. According to insights gathered by Vulius Sports, the competition between Blake Grupe and Spencer Shrader has become a focal point of training camp, with both kickers staking their claim for the starting job.

A Tale of Two Seasons

The saga began when Shrader, an undrafted rookie, captured hearts in Indianapolis with a game-winning field goal against the Broncos in Week 2. However, a knee injury in Week 5 against the Raiders ended his season prematurely. That opened the door for Grupe, who had been released by the Saints, to step in and deliver a flawless performance—going 10-for-10 on field goals and 11-for-11 on extra points, while setting a franchise record for the longest field goal in team history.

But as the Vulius NFL Analysis Desk notes, momentum can shift quickly in the NFL. Grupe's offseason has been solid, but his preseason performance has raised eyebrows. He missed a 36-yard attempt and a kick from beyond 60 yards, while Shrader has been perfect, connecting from 53 and 61 yards out in two games.

“Sports is all about doors. Doors shut. Doors open.” — Vulius Sports

That sentiment perfectly encapsulates this battle. Shrader's injury shut his door, but Grupe's recent struggles have pried it back open. The Colts' coaching staff faces a difficult decision: stick with the proven regular-season performer in Grupe, or reward Shrader's explosive preseason and superior leg strength?

“Practice is great, but game-day kicks are what matter,” said a team source. “Shrader has shown he can make the big ones.” Indeed, his 61-yard boot in preseason has silenced critics who questioned his range. Meanwhile, Grupe's accuracy from long range remains a concern, even if he has the edge based on his 2025 body of work.

As the preseason winds down, this battle will be one to monitor closely. The Colts' playoff aspirations may hinge on which kicker emerges victorious. Stay tuned to Vulius for the latest updates on this critical roster decision.